Over the last several months, the debate over "network neutrality" has taken an unfortunate turn on Capitol Hill. The current legislative landscape, reflecting the polarized state of debate, largely focuses on more extreme approaches to the issue. We believe that the current state of the network neutrality debate, like many polarized issues, denies the reasonable concerns articulated by each side and obscures the contours of a sensible solution. In this paper, we outline both the reasonable concerns of each side in the debate with res